Key Highlights
- A federal court issued a 2-1 ruling affirming that federal commodities law does not automatically preempt Maryland’s traditional police powers over gambling.
- Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown asserted that prediction market platform Kalshi must comply with the state’s rigorous sportsbook consumer protection and licensing mandates.
- Kalshi criticized the ruling as splintered and inconsistent, highlighting conflicting rationales across federal courts as the industry awaits potential U.S. Supreme Court resolution.
Federal Court Upholds Maryland’s Authority Over Prediction Markets
In a consequential legal development concerning the regulation of prediction platforms, a federal court panel reached a divided 2-1 outcome examining the boundary between federal commodities supervision and state gambling enforcement. Addressing the jurisdictional conflict, one of the three judges — Roger Gregory — wrote in his opinion, “Because the regulation of gambling has long been a matter of traditional state police power, I would not infer that Congress displaced Maryland’s concurrent authority absent a clear expression of its intent to do so.”
Maryland Enforces Consumer Protection Standards
State regulators moved swiftly to interpret the judicial findings as an affirmation of local licensing requirements. Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown said in a Wednesday statement means that “Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as every other sportsbook serving Maryland residents.”
Attorney General Anthony Brown further detailed the critical consumer safeguards embedded within state gaming legislation that separate them from federal financial oversight frameworks. “Under our licensing laws, sportsbooks must safeguard customer data, refrain from deceptive advertising, and stop marketing to people who are barred from betting or at risk of gambling harm,” Brown said. “Federal commodities rules were never designed to provide those safeguards.”
Kalshi Highlights Contradictory Judicial Opinions
The company is claiming all the recent legal conclusions are a jumbled mess in which federal courts are contradicting each other. From Kalshi’s perspective, the absence of a unified judicial doctrine underscores the regulatory uncertainty surrounding financial prediction contracts.
“Judges can’t agree with each other on why we’re wrong,” a Kalshi spokeswoman said. “This splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions, demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets.”
Why This Matters
Though the decisions are inconsistent, there’s a growing consistency in the strong majority of judges deciding that the industry is in the wrong. Despite the varying legal reasoning provided by individual judges, federal courts are frequently declining to shield prediction markets entirely behind federal commodity statutes when challenged by state authorities. But until the U.S. Supreme Court overrides the rulings, the different views will muddy the regulatory waters, leaving operators, state attorneys general, and market participants navigating a fractured and evolving regulatory landscape.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the court determine regarding Maryland’s jurisdiction?
The court issued a 2-1 ruling establishing that federal oversight does not displace Maryland’s traditional police power to enforce state gambling regulations, allowing state consumer protection rules to apply concurrently.
What mandates does Maryland expect Kalshi to follow?
According to Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown, Kalshi must adhere to state sportsbook licensing requirements, which include safeguarding user data, preventing deceptive advertising, and barring promotional outreach to individuals who are vulnerable or excluded from gambling.
What is Kalshi’s stance on the federal court ruling?
Kalshi contends that the ruling is fractured into three separate opinions and reflects conflicting decisions across the federal judiciary, arguing that no unified legal rationale exists against the operation of prediction markets.




