Key Highlights
- Former Haas team principal Guenther Steiner has questioned whether Lewis Hamilton has the profile required to lead Ferrari back to Formula 1 supremacy, suggesting Max Verstappen’s relentless approach could be better suited.
- Despite securing his maiden Ferrari victory at the Barcelona Catalunya Grand Prix in 2026, Hamilton’s partnership with Charles Leclerc has faced growing scrutiny following recent on-track incidents.
- Steiner’s remarks echo recent criticism from former grand prix winner Ralf Schumacher, who argued that the seven-time world champion never learned to serve as a team leader during his tenures at McLaren and Mercedes.
Guenther Steiner Weighs In on Ferrari Leadership Dynamics
Former Haas Formula 1 team principal Guenther Steiner has cast doubt over whether Lewis Hamilton possesses the right approach to orchestrate a championship-winning turnaround at Scuderia Ferrari. The debate centers on historical precedent at Maranello, where the Italian outfit famously enjoyed its most dominant eras when a commanding driver took full command of the organization, reminiscent of Michael Schumacher’s transformative reign in the late 1990s and early 2000s.
Speaking on The Red Flags Podcast, Steiner compared the current situation to previous marquee signings that failed to produce titles, pointing directly to two-time champion Fernando Alonso’s tenure with the team. But is he the guy who can make the team win?
Steiner asked. When strong drivers took over, they made it a success, but Fernando Alonso tried. Did he succeed? No. Do you think Lewis is the right guy to make this happen?
Comparing Lewis Hamilton and Max Verstappen
When the discussion shifted toward whether Red Bull Racing’s Max Verstappen would provide a more effective catalyst for Ferrari’s ambitions, Steiner highlighted the Dutchman’s uncompromising mentality inside an engineering garage. Assessing how Verstappen operates, Steiner explained: You know how Max is. He wouldn’t stop. He’s relentless. That could be the solution.
Podcast co-host Brian Muller offered an alternative perspective, stressing that Ferrari must fully capitalize on the pedigree of the driver they currently have under contract rather than lamenting unavailable alternatives. Well, they’re not getting Max anytime soon. So, what they have is Lewis, and if they’re not ready to drop things when you have a seven-time world champion who’s ready to make Ferrari great again, and you’re not ready to jump on that when it’s time, then you’ve got bigger problems,
Muller added.
Tensions and Milestones in the 2026 Campaign
Hamilton made the seismic move to Maranello ahead of the 2025 season following an illustrious 12-year stint at Mercedes, where he captured six of his seven world drivers’ championships. After experiencing a challenging debut year acclimatizing to Ferrari machinery, the 41-year-old veteran has delivered stronger performances in 2026. Highlighting that progress was his maiden victory for the Scuderia at the Barcelona Catalunya Grand Prix. With three rounds left in the championship, Hamilton sits fourth in the drivers’ standings.
However, recent race weekends have generated friction within the garage. Intra-team dynamics between Hamilton and teammate Charles Leclerc have come under heightened scrutiny following multiple wheel-to-wheel clashes on track, reigniting discussions about Ferrari’s management structure and hierarchy.
Ralf Schumacher’s Critique of Hamilton’s Leadership
Steiner’s observations align with recent critical comments made by former Formula 1 driver Ralf Schumacher, who claimed the Briton never learned how to lead a team
throughout his career.
Speaking on Sky Sports Germany’s Backstage Boxengasse podcast, Schumacher argued that Hamilton was never required to shoulder the organizational burden of steering team development during his earlier successes. Hamilton never learned how to lead a team, not under Toto Wolff and not under Ron Dennis,
Schumacher said. That was never his job anyway. He just had to get in the car and drive as fast as possible.
Schumacher concluded with a blunt assessment of how that environment influenced the veteran: You can see that, and it’s made him quite egotistical as well.
Why This Matters
Ferrari’s pursuit of a Formula 1 world championship has proven elusive for nearly two decades, with the team’s culture often demanding an authoritative driver figure capable of uniting technical departments and managing intense political pressures. Hamilton’s high-profile switch from Mercedes was seen as the marquee catalyst to break that drought. However, with intra-team friction rising alongside Charles Leclerc and contrasting opinions on whether Hamilton’s leadership style matches the template set by figures like Michael Schumacher, Ferrari faces crucial decisions regarding garage hierarchy and development direction as the 2026 season approaches its final three rounds.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did Guenther Steiner say about Lewis Hamilton and Max Verstappen?
Steiner questioned whether Hamilton has the ability to transform Ferrari into a consistent title-winning outfit, drawing comparisons to Fernando Alonso’s unsuccessful championship bids with the Scuderia. In contrast, Steiner pointed to Verstappen’s relentless attitude as an approach that might be more capable of driving institutional change at Maranello.
How has Lewis Hamilton performed with Ferrari in 2026?
Following a difficult initial season in 2025, Hamilton secured his first race win with Ferrari at the Barcelona Catalunya Grand Prix in 2026. Heading into the final three rounds of the championship, the 41-year-old driver occupies fourth place in the drivers’ standings, though his campaign has been marked by occasional on-track clashes with teammate Charles Leclerc.
Why did Ralf Schumacher criticize Lewis Hamilton’s leadership background?
Ralf Schumacher stated that Hamilton was never tasked with leading an organization during his tenures under McLaren team boss Ron Dennis or Mercedes team principal Toto Wolff, arguing that his focus was solely on driving fast, which Schumacher claims left him without traditional team-building experience.

