Key Highlights:
- A 29-year-old dating app user sparked viral discussion on Reddit after detailing recurring deception by high-earning men in their late 30s and early 40s regarding their marital status and children.
- The poster revealed that several men she encountered falsely claimed to be divorced or separated, with some allegedly abandoning their spouses and young children following childbirth.
- Commenters on the r/dating_advice community debated the psychological factors behind elite infidelity, while others warned against generalizing an entire demographic based on personal encounters.
Online Dating Deception Sparks Heated Debate on Reddit
Navigating modern dating platforms can often feel fraught with dishonesty, but one woman’s viral post on Reddit has shed light on a troubling pattern among high-achieving professionals. Writing on the r/dating_advice forum under the username u/medx_extreme on November 20, 2026, a 29-year-old woman shared her ongoing frustration with dating app matches in their late 30s and early 40s who routinely misrepresented their marital and family situations. The thread quickly caught the attention of the community, accumulating dozens of responses exploring why accomplished men engage in systematic deception about their personal lives.
According to the original poster, multiple men she met through dating services lied extensively about their relationships. Some asserted they were legally separated when they remained actively married, while others fabricated timelines, alleging they had been divorced for years. Additionally, some claimed they never intended to have children or insisted they only discovered pregnancies after initiating divorce filings. Disturbed by discrepancies in their stories, the woman took the step of contacting several of their wives. Based on these conversations, she alleged the men had been unfaithful and abandoned their partners shortly after childbirth, leaving behind children aged 1 to 5.
Elite Careers and the Psychology of Deceit
Expressing deep moral exhaustion with the dating scene, the woman voiced her anger over the impact these behaviors have on families. I’m just sick of meeting them,
she wrote. They’re the most monstrous men who put their wives through hell.
Seeking insight from mental health professionals within the forum, she asked: If you’re a psychologist, please let me know why,
noting that the men held prominent and demanding careers. One was an established cardiovascular surgeon, while another worked as an executive at a major insurance corporation. Their substantial professional achievements, she argued, made their calculated untruths even more perplexing.
They’re apparently highly intelligent,
she noted, adding, Yet they lie to the grave and think women will just buy into whatever they say.
Reflecting on their shared psychological profiles, she concluded that They just have a really high need for external validations,
observing that they often displayed bitterness, critical attitudes, and pretension from the initial interaction. Rather than flaunting luxury items, she explained, They’re flashy, not showing off materialistic things,
but demonstrated marked personality shifts following infidelity.
Community Reactions: Corporate Culture vs. Unfair Generalizations
Community members offered varied perspectives on the recurring phenomenon. One respondent referenced the workplace psychology book Snakes in Suits, claiming individuals in corporate hierarchy or elite professions may exhibit sociopathic tendencies, though no formal diagnosis or clinical proof was provided. Encouraging the poster to rely on her intuition, the commenter wrote, You always know deep down when someone’s being honest/genuine or not,
and advised, Don’t waste time and energy trying to change anyone else.
Reminding her to maintain hope, they added, Change comes from within, of their own volition,
noting that There are truly wonderful men out there who want to find true love as well,
before concluding, Just tune your filters a bit.
Another user urged the poster not to blame herself for the deceit, remarking, it’s[sic] wild how they all use the same script,
and reassuring her with, You’re not attracting them.
That commenter theorized that these men rely on their prestige as a smokescreen, asserting, You’re just unfortunately running into the same type of guy who thinks he can get away with it because of his job title.
However, not everyone agreed with the sweeping characterization. A 39-year-old divorced father pushed back firmly against grouping all men in his age bracket together, writing: So if I picked 3 lying women (true story) – does it mean all women are liars?
He explained that he had never misled prospective partners, took a two-year hiatus from dating post-divorce, and served as the sole primary caregiver for his 13-year-old son, arguing that the poster’s rhetoric meant […] you accuse me personally in lying too,
.
Why This Matters
The dialogue surrounding the Reddit post highlights broader, ongoing challenges in online dating safety, user verification, and the emotional toll of romantic misrepresentation. As matchmaking applications remain the primary conduit for modern relationships, users frequently face bad-faith actors who conceal preexisting marriages, domestic commitments, and financial realities. The discussion also reflects growing consumer scrutiny over whether platforms should implement stricter identity and background verification to protect daters from dishonesty, manipulation, and the potential emotional fallout of unvetted encounters.
Frequently Asked Questions
What specific lies did the Reddit user uncover on dating apps?
The poster reported that several men in their late 30s and early 40s fabricated their marital status by claiming to be separated or long divorced when they were still married. She also alleged that some matches lied about their attitudes toward fatherhood and child custody timelines.
What professions were associated with the men in the post?
The woman identified some of the men as high-earning professionals, including a cardiovascular surgeon and a corporate executive at a prominent insurance firm, arguing that their career accomplishments seemed at odds with their deceptive behavior.
Were the allegations against these men verified?
No. The claims originate from an unverified public discussion thread on the r/dating_advice subreddit, and the personal identities of the poster, the commenters, and the individuals referenced have not been independently confirmed.




