Key Highlights
- A viral video revealed that over 100 LinkedIn job postings by Canadian recruiting firm David Joseph and Company inadvertently published internal recruiter notes, candidate names, and employment statuses.
- The exposed listings featured internal criteria such as identifying candidates who were “recently laid off or between jobs” as an automatic rejection, alongside sensitive hiring evaluations.
- AI recruitment platform Contrario investigated the incident, took immediate corrective steps, and determined the disclosure was likely due to human error rather than a system defect.
Viral Investigation Uncovers Internal Recruiting Notes on Public Job Listings
A recent investigation shared on social media has put a spotlight on data privacy and automated hiring tools after a recruiter discovered confidential evaluation criteria and applicant details published directly on LinkedIn job ads. Content creator Jillian, who posts about career trends and recruiting under the handle @jilliandoesbranding on TikTok, analyzed a suspicious LinkedIn listing sent to her by an associate. Her resulting video quickly gained widespread attention across the platform, amassing over 471,000 views and more than 1,100 comments.
Upon reviewing the initial listing, Jillian identified glaring discrepancies beneath the standard job description. The post not only outlined role expectations and mandatory qualifications but also displayed backend operational evaluations that were never intended for public consumption.
“It looked really weird because on the job posting itself was the role, the qualifications, the requirements. And then below that were a bunch of like internal recruiter notes about the role itself, and then a section that said red flags and green flags in terms of what they were looking for the candidate, including a red flag that said recently laid off or between jobs hard pass. And then below that was a list of names, full first and last names, and the companies that those people currently worked at, along with single lines about whether they were being considered or not for the role,” she said.
Dozens of Listings Found Containing Candidate PII and Screening Flags
Scope of the Data Exposure Across Recruitment Platforms
Spurred by the unexpected exposure of private data, Jillian expanded her review to determine whether the incident was an isolated mishap or part of a wider issue. Her inquiry revealed that the company behind the post was utilizing David Joseph and Company, an AI-assisted recruitment agency operating out of Canada. When she audited the agency’s catalog of 133 active job postings, she found that 110 of them featured the same internal recruiting assessments, candidate evaluations, and full identifying details.
The recruitment operation involved multiple integrated systems: David Joseph and Company relied on an artificial intelligence platform called Contrario—which advertises AI-powered hiring oversight combined with human management—while the postings and applicant records also surfaced on Manatal, a cloud-based career portal and applicant tracking system.
Contrario Identifies Human Error and Rectifies Listings
Following her discovery, Jillian attempted to alert the organizations involved. While David Joseph and Company and Manatal did not respond to her outreach, Contrario initiated an internal review after being contacted.
“I didn’t hear back from David Joseph and Co or Manatal about it, but I did hear back from Contrario and they discovered what was happening and they immediately corrected it. And they did a scan across all of their other clients to make sure that this wasn’t happening, to ensure that it wasn’t a platform issue, but that it was likely a human issue,” she said.
Public Reaction and Growing Concerns Over AI in Hiring
The revelation that active job seekers had their personal information, current workplaces, and screening assessments published publicly generated significant pushback online. Commenters debated both the competency of the recruitment staff and the privacy ramifications for the named candidates whose career prospects and current employer relationships could be compromised.
Reacting to the strict screening criteria revealed in the posts, one user wrote, “I think someone at that company will now be in between jobs,” while another noted the irony: “Lemme guess, one of the job requirements is ‘attention to detail,’”.
Other viewers highlighted the severity of publicly exposing candidate information without consent. “That’s a violation of personal data,” one commenter asserted, raising questions about whether affected professionals would seek legal remedies against the responsible firms. Others pointed to unchecked reliance on automation, with one commenter writing, “People using Al and NOT CHECKING THE WORK is becoming a real issue,” prompting additional users to share similar anecdotes of confidential recruiting data leaking onto live job boards.
Why This Matters
The incident highlights the growing vulnerabilities at the intersection of automated recruitment pipelines and human administrative oversight. As talent acquisition teams increasingly deploy artificial intelligence and third-party applicant tracking systems to manage high volumes of job postings, data handling procedures become critical. When software bridges between platforms such as Contrario, Manatal, and LinkedIn fail to properly isolate internal notes from customer-facing fields, candidate personally identifiable information (PII) can be exposed. Furthermore, the incident sheds light on controversial, unadvertised screening practices—such as summarily rejecting unemployed or recently laid-off workers—raising transparency concerns across the modern hiring ecosystem.
Frequently Asked Questions
What kind of candidate information was exposed in the LinkedIn postings?
The compromised postings displayed full first and last names of job applicants, the names of the companies where they were currently employed, specific single-line evaluations regarding their candidacy, and internal screening directives outlining candidate “red flags” and “green flags.”
Which companies were involved in the job posting incident?
The situation centered around Canadian recruitment firm David Joseph and Company, which managed 133 listings. The workflow also utilized Contrario, an AI recruitment platform that provides oversight tools, and Manatal, a career-site software platform where the listings and data were also displayed.
Was the issue caused by software automation or manual oversight?
According to Contrario’s response following an audit across its client portfolio, the company determined that the leak was not caused by an underlying platform malfunction, but was instead the result of human error during the listing setup process.




